Anderson Cooper’s Favorite Cookies: Compost Cookies

  • As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

    Okay, I promise this is my last Anderson Cooper post for the month. You guys are probably sick of it, but I promised I’d talk about the cookies I brought him and the production crew!

    Well, here they are! These compost cookies are Christina Tosi’s creations. She’s the pastry chef at Momofuku’s Milk Bar in NYC. She has the most insane creations and they all are like crack, I mean, she has a pie that’s called “crack pie.”

    It’s definitely all in her process. You’d think it’s crazy but beating the wet ingredients for 7 minutes is really necessary. If you’re pressed for time or you have no patience, these cookies probably aren’t for you. However, I do think you should spare some time for these babies. They’re the most ridiculous yet most well-made cookies I’ve ever tasted.

    When I was deciding what cookie to bring Anderson Cooper, I decided to use my trusty friend, Google, and figure out what his favorite cookie was. He’s the world’s pickiest eater. In fact, he eats the same thing every day, and on the show when I was there, he admitted to just ordering off the children’s menu whenever he’s at a hotel or restaurant because it’s simpler. I don’t really blame him – I mean, chicken tenders and french fries are total comfort foods for me, haha

    Anyway, so after searching Google, it was said that when Anderson was filling in on Regis & Kelly, he brought the audience his favorite cookies, which were Christina Tosi’s compost cookies.

    Anderson, for being a picky eater, you have great taste, my friend.

    These cookies have EVERYTHING in them.

    Pretzels, potato chips, oatmeal, coffee grounds, chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, graham cracker crumbs…

    I feel like I should be saying, “and then I threw in gummy worms and skittles!” haha

    Again, the recipe has ingredients that you probably aren’t used to in regular baking but don’t omit them. You’ll ruin the cookie. Milk powder? Go get it. Beating the batter for 7-8 minutes? Do it. Chilling them before baking? Do it. Following the directions to a T? You better believe it!

    Ok, so I’m going to now photobomb you with how I packaged these cookies for Anderson Cooper. If you want the recipe, it’s below the cut. And yes, you’re gonna WANT the recipe. You HAVE to make these and see for yourself why everyone raves about them!

    I individually wrapped each cookie & stuck my business card in each one.

    Then to protect these precious babies, I placed them in two bubble wrappers and sealed them with my personalized stickers.

    They fit perfectly in this box.

    And the box fit perfectly in this brown kraft bag I bought at the craft store. Stuck more of my stickers on there and of course, I didn’t forget the twine ;)

    4 from 2 votes
    Print

    Anderson Cooper's Favorite Cookies: Compost Cookies

    These cookies have a little bit of everything in them!
    Prep Time: 1 hr 20 mins
    Cook Time: 18 mins
    Total Time: 1 hr 38 mins
    Servings (adjustable, but please note that results, timing, and cookware may vary when adjusting servings): 2 dozen
    Calories: 310kcal
    5 Hassle-Free Ways to Simplify MealtimeSign up here for all the secrets!

    Ingredients

    • 2 sticks unsalted butter, softened
    • 1 cup granulated sugar
    • 2/3 cup tightly packed dark brown sugar
    • 1 tbsp corn syrup
    • 1 egg
    • 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
    • 1 1/3  cups bread flour, you may use AP flour instead if you don't have it on hand
    • 1/2 tsp baking powder
    • 1/4 tsp baking soda
    • 1 tsp kosher salt
    • 3/4 cup mini chocolate chips
    • 1 cup butterscotch chips
    • 1/2 cup of graham crust, see below
    • 1/3 cup old-fashioned rolled oats
    • 2 1/2 tsp ground coffee
    • 2 cups plain potato chips
    • 1 cup mini pretzels

    For the graham crust:

    • 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs
    • 1/4 cup dry milk powder
    • 2 tbsp granulated sugar
    • 3/4 tsp kosher salt
    • 1/2 stick unsalted butter, melted, 4 tbsp
    • 1/4 cup heavy cream

    Instructions

    • Line baking sheets with parchment paper or silicone baking mats.
    • In a large bowl, whisk flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt together. Set aside.
    • In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream together butter, sugars, and corn syrup on medium-high for 2-3 minutes then scrape down the sides of the bowl. Then add in the egg and vanilla extract and beat for 7-8 minutes.
    • Slowly add in the flour mixture and mix until everything is just about coming together, no longer than 1 minute.
    • Still on low speed, add the chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, graham crust, oats, and ground coffee, and mix for 30 seconds.
    • Then add the potato chips and pretzels until just incorporated.
    • Using a medium sized cookie scoop, portion out dough onto your prepared baking sheets. Pat the top domes of the cookies flat. Wrap the sheet pan tightly in plastic wrap and place in refrigerator to chill for up to one hour. Do NOT bake your cookies at room temperature. They will not bake correctly.
    • Heat oven to 375 degrees. Take the cookie sheets out of the refrigerator and place inside oven. Bake for 18 minutes. They should be faintly brown on the edges but still yellow in the center. Give them an extra minute or two if that's not the case. The idea is to have the outside edge a bit crispy with the insides chewy and soft.
    • Let cookies cool on baking sheet for 10 minutes before transferring to a wire rack to cool completely.
    • Store in an airtight container for up to 1 week or up to 1 month in a freezer.

    For the graham crust:

    • Toss the graham crumbs, milk powder, sugar and salt with your hands in a medium bowl to evenly distribute your dry ingredients.
    • Whisk the melted butter and cream together and pour over your dry ingredients. The mixture should hold its shape if you squeeze it in the palm of your hands. If it doesn't, it's not moist enough, so add another 1 tbsp. or so of melted butter.
    • Use required amount in compost cookie recipe and store the rest in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 1 month.

    Notes

    Source: Momofuku Milk Bar Cookbook
    Nutrition Facts
    Anderson Cooper's Favorite Cookies: Compost Cookies
    Amount Per Serving (1 cookie)
    Calories 310 Calories from Fat 144
    % Daily Value*
    Fat 16g25%
    Carbohydrates 38g13%
    Fiber 1g4%
    Sugar 26g29%
    Protein 2g4%
    * Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
    *Nutrition facts are an estimate and not guaranteed to be accurate. 
  • 95 Comments
    Julie Wampler of Table for Two
    Meet The Author: Julie Wampler
    Dinner for Two Cookbook
    Order My Cookbook!

    Dinner for Two

    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Comments

  • dixya @ food, pleasure, and health says:

    this is like THE MOST LEGIT cookie recipe I have come across. Such unique ingredients and for a picky eater like him – I am sure this cookie is worth every bite. Loved how you packed those cookies!

  • Janet from Vancouver says:

    Just tried the recipe, followed the directions closely. The oven temperature was too hot, the cookies are a little sweet, didn’t really puff up that much, I would recommend not flattening them in order to have a thicker cookie.

    My family didn’t love it.

  • Angela @ Another Bite Please says:

    these cookies look crazy good…and so cute how you packaged everything!!!

  • Stephanie @ Eat. Drink. Love. says:

    These cookies look incredible! I love all the goodness stuffed in!

  • kelly @ kellybakes says:

    I’ve eaten the compost cookies at Milk Bar and wasn’t all that impressed, to be 100% honest. Yours, however, look amazing! I think it’s got something to do with the huge chunks of chips and chocolate. THESE I could easily see myself getting addicted to! (And I love Anderson Cooper! I’ve been geeking out over your posts!)

  • Lynne says:

    I made these today, and because we are a family of two, shared them with the family across the street. I am now their favorite neighbor. :-)

    Very high maintenance recipe, but boy are they delicious!

    • Julie says:

      Haha, this comment made me laugh. So happy they turned out well for you :)

  • Sandy says:

    I made it and loved it. The only thing that they were flat

    • Julie says:

      So glad you loved it! They’re supposed to be flat so no worries! :)

  • Kat says:

    I was wondering about the pretzals & potato chips. Are they to be added whole? Not chopped or crushed in any way?

    • Julie says:

      Added whole. It’ll all get crushed up with the mixing and dispersed throughout the dough :) you’ll have some bigger chunks of pretzels and some bigger chunks of chips – that’s what you’re looking for! Don’t overmix :)

  • Anne I says:

    Loved this unique recipe. I made them this weekend and although they kind of melted into each other and I had to cut them up later like brownies, they tasted awesome. I love the salty-sweet combination and everyone who tried them raved about them too. So, definitely making them again :) (Since I still have some of that graham crust left over, it’s only good sense!)

  • Winnie says:

    These sound so delish, I love salty/sweet combo. I am a crafter, so I love your packaging too! I can’t wait to bake these!

  • suzanne says:

    i’m so excited to make these! looking to bake something special for a very special aunt that always makes unique dishes. she will LOVE these! quick question – regular coffee grounds or instant?

  • Jayde Herriford says:

    I am so excited to make these this weekend for my husband’s 35th birthday! With that said I’m a little worried as I recently sold my kitchenaide stand mixer, do you think I will be able to accomplish this dish with just a hand-held? Next do you crush up the pretzels at all or just mix them in whole? I can’t wait to comment on how they turned out.

    • Julie says:

      Hi Jayde – I’m not sure if the hand-held will work too well with this particular recipe because it doesn’t have as much motor power as the stand mixer or a big enough blade to whip much air into the butter mixture. You can certainly try, though! You mix the pretzels in whole.

  • Sue fish says:

    Question, if you don’t have a refrigerator big enough to handle numerous cookie sheets, what do you do with remaining dough between batches?
    First time trying these. Does chilling the dough in refrig count if not out on cookie sheet?

    • Julie says:

      Hi Sue, I highly recommend portioning out the dough into balls and then putting them in the fridge because if you just put the entire bowl of dough in the fridge to chill, it becomes SO hard that it’s impossible to scoop (while I was testing this recipe, I did that the first time – not fun!). If you don’t have a fridge big enough to handle cookie sheets, you can always line a plate with parchment paper and place dough balls onto them that way to chill and then transfer to a baking sheet when ready. Hope this helps!

  • Michelle says:

    For the ground coffee, do you use instant coffee, or just regular coffee grounds ? Please respond asap, I’m dying to make these. They look awesome. Thanks :)

    • Julie says:

      I just used regular coffee grounds.

      • Dawn says:

        Coffee grounds as in what you have after your morning cuppa?

        • Julie says:

          No, as in the dried coffee grounds that you scoop out from a bag for your morning cuppa :)

  • Daisy says:

    I’ve been looking forward to making these for days, but am disappointed in the results. The butterscotch chips overwhelmed almost the other flavors. I looked at Christina Tosi’s recipe on another site, and there should have been only 1/2 cup of butterscotch chips (and they’re supposed to be minis). The recipe also called for 2 T glucose. I don’t know how much difference that would have made.

    The other problem was that, when I checked these after only 15 minutes, most of them were already burned. I ended up having to throw away most of them.

    There used to be a restaurant in town that made these, and they were wonderful. I’m not sure if I’d make these again, but they’d probably be fine with a couple of little adjustments.

    • Barbie says:

      I lowered the oven to 325 with better results. I agree way too much butterscotch chips. That’s all you taste and smell.

  • Daisy says:

    This is an update to my comments of a few days ago. My family loved these cookies. They do usually like things a little sweeter than I do, so the amount of butterscotch chips didn’t bother them as much as it did me. It sounds like I’ll be expected to make these again! Will definitely cut back the butterscotch and reduce banking temp to 350.

  • Barbie says:

    These look like such yummy cookies. First off the oven should be at 325 not 375. The first batch sound like a stone, they were so hard. There is way to much sugar in total. The cookies should have a savoriness to them. All you get is sweet upon sweet. I will be making these again with a few tweaking, I love the idea of potato chips and pretzels in a cookie.

  • Saloni says:

    How many cookies do you get in this batch? It says yield 2…

    • Julie says:

      sorry, I converted recipe plugins and I guess it didn’t convert correctly. It should be 2 dozen :)

  • mahina says:

    I’m confused to when & where do you put the graham cracker crusted mixture????

    • Julie says:

      You add it in step #5. The instructions from step 11 and beyond are for the graham cracker crust that you add into step #5.

  • Tara Fields says:

    I don’t understand how the graham crust is incorporated?

    • Julie says:

      It’s added in in step #5

  • Leigh Anne Siebert says:

    I made these cookies exactly to the recipe. It was minus 6 Celsius here in Ontario, so I covered them and put them in the garage for 4 hours.
    They spread out way too much and became hard. Cooked them in a 375 convection oven.
    I made a second batch the next day. Changed the Flour to 2 cups, decreased the white sugar to 3/4 cups, increased the chocolate chips to 1 cup and decreased the butterscotch chips to 3/4 cup. Only because I found them too sweet. Froze the cookies for a couple of hours
    Way better cookie, Holds it`s shape and not as sweet. I also used whole wheat flour, only because I wanted to use it up. Soft cookie.

  • smita says:

    do you know what is the difference in the cookie between using bread flour and all purpose flour in this recipe? I know that these two types of flour very differently in baking but how in this complex cookie? I have both so wondering what I should use? Thanks!

    • Julie says:

      I actually don’t know the difference for this recipe. I think it might make a softer cookie? Sorry I don’t have a good answer for you!

  • Grimble Squeem says:

    I might be inclined to order your cookbook, but I would need to know how many pictures of Anderson Cooper are in it. More than there are recipes, I would venture to guess. Your infatuation with Anderson Cooper teeters on the razor thin line between absolutely hilarious and downright scary. If you get served with a no contact order, you might want to find another sissy to fawn over . The penalty for STALKING is quite serious these days.

  • Milann Daugherty says:

    I ‘d love to try these but by body can’t tolerate caffeine. You said not to leave anything out. How bad would it be to leave out the coffee grounds? Thanks

    • Julie says:

      It wouldn’t be “bad” cause you don’t like coffee as it is so I don’t think you’d miss the flavour.

  • Bridget says:

    Just made the cookies they’re delicious. My question is why the corn syrup and the coffee grounds?

    • Julie Wampler says:

      For the corn syrup – not sure. Coffee grounds enhance flavor!

    • Elle C says:

      Hey I made these cookies and they turned out great. I only used 1 tablespoon of glucose, 1/2 of butterscotch chips, and used 1 3/4 cup of flour. I added mini half pretzels to the cookie tops and some soft caramel bits after they come out of the oven. Looks fab Thanks!!

  • Bridget says:

    Oh an by the way I made these cookies and thought they were delicious. I used a 375 oven watched them and they came out perfectly, a little crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside.
    Some of the comments here make it sound like the temperature of the oven was incorrect when in fact I found it perfect. I usually follow a recipe the way it’s originally intended and then like any good cook adjust things For my preferences.

  • 5 Hassle-Free Ways to Simplify Mealtime
    Would you like to receive notifications for the latest recipes and updates?