A simple russet potato recipe
I know this seems like a simple post (and I’m sure some of you think it’s a cop-out ’cause I’ve had emails with people telling me my pizza recipes are cop-outs, haha) but you won’t believe the number of requests I get on roasting potatoes and what our favorite way to roast potatoes is.
So here it is in all its glory!
Our favorite way to roast potatoes, specifically with russet potatoes.
Jason loves this seasoning blend that I use and quite frankly, I do too!
Sometimes a simple russet potato recipe is all you need.
Nothing needs to be too fancy!
How do you get a crispy exterior?
High temperature is your friend.
The oil on the potato’s exterior will crisp it up.
You want that crispy exterior so don’t be afraid to use a higher temperature.
Do you have to use a russet potato?
No, you could virtually use any potato and use the same seasoning blend.
Can you leave the skin on the russet potato?
Yes, absolutely.
I actually keep the skin on for mini red potatoes, mini rainbow potatoes, and fingerlings.
I am just used to peeling russet potatoes and baking potatoes for some reason.
How do you know when the potatoes are done?
When you can stick a fork into it and easily slide it in and out, it’s done!
My potatoes are taking longer to cook
This may be because of how thick you cut them.
If they aren’t cooked through at the end of baking time, let them cook longer.
If you love potatoes and are looking for more russet potato recipes, these may be of interest to you:
- Cheesy hashbrown casserole
- Curly fries
- Twice-baked loaded ranch potatoes
- Slow cooker chorizo, potato, and two-bean chili
Our Favorite Way to Roast Potatoes
Ingredients
- 2 large russet potatoes, peeled, rinsed, and diced into quarter cubes
- 2 tablespoons olive oil
- 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
- 1/2 teaspoon Italian seasoning
- 1/4 teaspoon sweet paprika powder
- 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
- 1/4 teaspoon ground black pepper
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 425 degrees Fahrenheit and lightly spray a baking sheet with cooking spray.
- In a large bowl, toss together potatoes oil, and seasoning.
- Pour potatoes onto baking sheet in an even layer.
- Bake on the middle rack in the oven for 25-30 minutes or until potatoes are tender. Flip the potatoes halfway through the cooking process.
I love roast potatoes! We normally just do ours plain in oil or duck/goose fat with a little salt and pepper but love the idea of using a seasoning blend like this!
I love this! simple preparation of potatoes. I don’t watch TV….so no screaming ;)
We love roasted potatoes and C begs me to make them at least twice a week. I’m going to have to try your method next time I do – they look fabulous, Julie!
Sometimes it’s the simple recipes that hit the spot!
This is the best way to roast potatoes and there’s no substitute for olive oil and good seasoning! Thanks for sharing, Julie!
I love that you talked about Game of Thrones today! So pumped for Sunday. Also, those potatoes, totally making!!
We eat a lot of roasted potatoes….various kinds. They are great, quick and versatile.
No way is this a cop-out recipe :-)
Who doesn’t love a good roasted potato recipe?? And that crisp exterior-a must.
I make roasted potatoes frequently especially with our roasted leg of lamb for Easter. The only addition I make is to add a lot of lemon juice and chopped garlic instead of garlic powder. Our grandchildren love them too.
These look great. Not sure how to make those cute wedges like in your photos. They look so small. Did you first slice the potatoes lengthwise, then quarter them? Also, much easier and very flavor-ful to use only Lawry’s seasoning salt. Only “spice” we use on our potatoes.
I sliced the potato in half (not lengthwise, the shorter side) then in half again and then diced them into quarters.
When you say you cut in half (got it), then half again, are you flopping the two sides down flat & slicing each half not lengthwise again? I always cut too big of chunks and it takes forever to cook!
Yes, so after the second halve…you put the flat sides of the potato down on the cutting board. Then I slice in half lengthwise and then I quarter them. Does that make sense? I might take a photo of this this weekend to be more clear. So if you want to come back for a step by step, I’ll try to have it up by the end of the weekend!
Roasted potatoes are always a favorite, love your recipe!
What a great way to enjoy some potatoes!
Oh yum! These roasted potatoes look delightful!!
Roasted potatoes are definitely my favorite way to eat potatoes. This seasoning looks delicious. My boyfriend and I went to see the last two episodes of GOT in IMAX and let me tell you…it was AWESOME! I can’t wait for Sunday.
WE Looooove roasted potatoes, I swear we have them every week! Love!! xo
roasted potatoes are one of my fav thing ever!! yumm
I haven’t had roasted potatoes in so long! I love how simple your seasonings are too!! I always have plenty of those around ;)
Roasted Potatoes are a must at our house. I use a similar recipe to this and it’s always perfect. These potatoes look super delicious!
Those look so crispy and perfect! I love all the seasonings on each piece :) And OMG I’m the same way at the TV. It’s so annoying; I wish I could jump in there and slap some characters, ha!
I love roasted potatoes, can’t beat it
these look awesome and I am a total GOT psycho and can’t wait!!!
I actually made some roasted potatoes tonight, but my favorite seasoning to use is Trader Joe’s 21 Seasoning Salute. Yum!
I made these once and my husband now asks for them all the time. I have made them for dinner and breakfast. Great recipe! Thanks.
I tried this recipe last night to go with a new fish recipe. Sometimes you need a litte inspiration even when it comes to bringing things back to basics as this recipe does. Well, these potatoes saved the night! The fish recipe was complicated and a little dissapointing. However we loved the potatoes! Thanks for your recipe.
Thanks for the great recipe! Perfectly seasoned and delicious.
Growing up, whenever my mom made oven roasted potatoes, it was always red potatoes mixed with a little olive oil and a packet of onion soup mix. I loved it, but this sounds like a simpler tastier version of that.
I must try it!!
My daughter made these we loved them I’m making them tonight and btw can’t wait for the new season of Game of Thrones we are huge fans thanks for sharing
Laura
This was so easy to make. I had some blood orange infused olive oil and decided to use it instead of the regular olive oil and it was delicious. Thank you for the recipe idea.
So delicious! Needed a quick and easy side for dinner tonight and this was it! Enjoyed by all. Thank you for sharing!
how early can I peel and cut potatoes, guests coming @ 6 tonight?
sorry, i don’t monitor comments/the blog all day. apologies for getting to you late. you can do them as early as you want and just keep them in a water bath so they don’t dry out
Olive oil Old Bay perfection!
I found the quartering answer in other notes on your website.
Thanks for the recipe
I haven’t made this yet, but it does look simple and good. However, can you roast the potatoes with the skins on? There are so many good-for-you nutrients in the skins I prefer to keep them on. And a totally unrelated to cooking question: do you have/did you have a relative who was an astronomy professor back in the early 70’s? I attended UC Santa Cruz and had a class with a Professor Joseph Wampler. I really liked him and it was a great class. I will also be considering buying your cookbook—finding recipes for two people (just me and my husband) can be difficult!
Yes, absolutely!! We keep the skin on for baby fingerlings and whatnot so definitely keep skin on if you want! And no, haha – Wampler is my married name! I don’t believe my husband’s side of the family had an astronomy professor though!
These were really good! I did convection roast (400 degrees) and it only took about 15 minutes!
Glad to hear this!
Thanks Julie for your russet potato recipe. Appreciate you and think you are super sweet.
Thanks Judy!
I will get your cookbook Dinner for Two! Always looking for recipes for husband and me! Tryi g roasted potatoes tonight!
Awesome!
Trying this today the only thing I change was Olive oil spray because that’s all I had but excited to try them, thanks for the recipe
Made the oven roasted russet potatoes (partially peeled), which came out perfectly and deliciously! Thank you. Btw, instead of “Italian seasoning,” used Grill Masters’ Garlic & Herb Seasoning.
Tried this recipe and LOVED it!! A wonderful potatoe went with my bbq ribs
Delicious!!! I stumbled across this recipe about a month ago and I’ve already made it 5 times. Both my husband and I love these potatoes. They are simple to make and so flavorful. Thanks so much for the easy-to-follow recipe.
Made these last night – normally my teens can take or leave potatoes. Last night I made 6 potatoes worth and they all were eaten!! The girls came back after dinner to finish them up. They asked me to make them again this week. Super easy recipe for very amazing potatoes💕
My teenage girls loved these potatoes. They have been quick to pass judgment on other roasted potato recipes in the past. This dish is a great side for the meat and potatoes bunch you have to feed. We give it two thumbs up!
I am used to cooking roast potatoes with flour so I was a bit uncertain as to how these would turn out… but they were delicious! I used garlic salt instead of powder and they were still very yummy. Highly recommend!
I know this is an older post, but found it and made it when my mom gave me some potatoes. My teen girls asked me to make it again the following week. They have never asked me to make a potato recipe again! And I’m about to make them for the third time in as many weeks now ❤️